The Italian Election: American Voters and “The Southern Question”
The Italian Election: American Voters and “The Southern Question”
(April 24, 2008)Comments posted by i-Italy bloggers Stanton Burnett and Marina Melchionda regarding the recent Italian elections place the outcome of that election solidly in the 150 year tradition conceptualize and characterized as “The Southern Question?”
In 1860 Garibaldi’s army “liberated” the people of southern Italy. However, the people did not feel liberated.
They revolted against what they perceived to be a conquering northern Italian regime. A vicious civil war ensued between the southern “Brigandage” and a northern Piedmont Army that razed whole southern towns such as Pontelandolfo for supporting the “Brigandage”.
As the war dragged on for years, bleeding the northern military and treasury, northerners became preoccupied with the south; giving rise in the 1870’s to a journalistic and literary tradition know as “The Southern Question”. Specifically, the question: ‘what could be done to incorporate the people of the south into a harmonious nation state –Italy’? By the 1880’s the federal government had de facto (if not de jure) decided upon a radical solution to the problem – export it.
Back in 1863 Nino Bixio, while working for a parliamentary commission inquiring into the problem of the Brigandage, wrote “… [southern Italy] is a country that should be depopulated and its inhabitants sent to Africa…” That same year the parliament passed the “Pica Law which grafted transportation onto the system of punishment”; i.e. southerners were transported away from their homes for supporting the revolution (see: “Darkest Italy” by John Dickie). Ideas of depopulation became a reality with the mass emigration of millions of southern Italians between circa 1880 and 1920.
However, the Southern Question persisted as evidence by Gramsci’s renowned article by that name in 1926. While the Fascists were not sympathetic to his communist analysis, they fully recognized the need to deal with the question. Traveling in Sicily in 1936, Jerre Mangione (“Mount Allegro”), albeit in anti-Fascist mocking tones, reports seeing Fascist public works projects and attempts to increase the efficiency of the train system, which was necessary for an efficient economy.
On June 2nd 1946Italy celebrated the birth of the Republic. The Fascist and the House of Savoy monarchy (that the Brigandage fought) were gone; but, not the Southern Question. In 1962, Luigi Barsini devoted a chapter in his book “The Italians”, to “the ancient and puzzling Problem del Mezzogiorno” (i.e. the Southern Question.)
In 1983 Nelson Moe (an American student in Perugia) on a train trip, indicated to a lady that he was going to Naples. Her reply: “Didn’t I know that this was a filthy, dangerous city, full of hucksters and thieves? Didn’t I know that the south was like Africa?” Her vehemence so stunned him and stimulated his interest that he eventually researched and wrote “The View from Vesuvius: Italian Culture and the Southern Question.” In 1998 interest in the question had not waned: CUNY anthropologist Jane Schneider published a multidiscipline anthology of essays “Italy’s ‘Southern Question.” In 2002 the scholarly interests continued with the publication of an extraordinary source document study; “Darkest Italy: The Nation and the Stereotypes of the Mezzogiorno, 1860-1900” by John Dickie.
Finally, this month two i-Italy bloggers placed the recent Italian election solidly in the Southern Question tradition:
“That the South is a serious drag on Italian economic performance in the context of the new Europe is no new revelation. Stefano Vaccara and I, in a study published in 1999 by Washington’s Center for Strategic and International Studies, found that not only was the North-South gap dramatic, but that the trends were in the wrong direction, a situation that was largely masked in Brussels where most economic and social statistics are national statistics.” (Stanton H. Burnett April 11, 2008 “Understanding Italian Politics”)
“Most of the votes [Berlusconi] has gained come from the South of Italy, where unemployment and economic discomfort afflict a larger portion of the population…“the “Southern question” is still a big issue here in Italy. In effect I could easily affirm that it is gaining much more political relevance nowadays with unemployment growing in the South as many companies are closing…the Southern question is gaining renovated relevancy, so much that both Berlusconi and Veltroni have made of it one of the most important issues, if the not THE most important, of their electoral campaign…Berlusconi is seen as the answer to all southern problems. He promised to solve the garbage crisis in Naples, to put – once again – the Southern question at the top of his political agenda” (Marina Melchionda April 15, 2008 “Opinions on Italian Elections” –comment section)
In conclusion, no matter how proficient Americans of Italian descent become in Italian language conjugations and declensions, or how many trips they take to ancient and Renaissance Italian tourist sites, they will not know their heritage or be able to vote meaningfully in Italian elections unless and until they know and understand “The Southern Question.”
DISCLAIMER: Posts published in i-Italy are intended to stimulate a debate in the Italian and Italian-American Community and sometimes deal with controversial issues. The Editors are not responsible for, nor necessarily in agreement with the views presented by individual contributors.
© ALL RIGHTS RESERVED - RIPRODUZIONE VIETATA.This work may not be reproduced, in whole or in part, without prior written permission.
Questo lavoro non può essere riprodotto, in tutto o in parte, senza permesso scritto.
-
This Blog
-
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Most Commented
South of Rome–West of Ellis Island | i-ITALY
Hi, just wanted to say, I loved this blog post. It was practical. Keep on posting!
South of Rome–West of Ellis Island | i-ITALY
Thanks for sharing your info. I truly appreciate your efforts and I will be waiting for your further write ups thank you once again.
South of Rome–West of Ellis Island | i-ITALY
May I just say what a relief to uncover somebody who truly knows what they're discussing on the web. You certainly realize how to bring a problem to light and make it important. More and more people really need to read this and understand this side of the story. I can't believe you are not more popular because you most certainly have the gift. payday loans
South of Rome–West of Ellis Island | i-ITALY
I was very happy to uncover this web site. I need to to thank you for ones time for this wonderful read!! I definitely savored every little bit of it and i also have you book-marked to see new information on your web site. quick loans
Payday advance
duoneiin http://paydayloansnse.co.uk/ Payday advance 9854 http://paydayloansnse.info/ cash advance 1929 http://paydayloansnse.com/ fast cash advance NbRwfH http://paydayloansnse.ca/ payday loan Canada >:-[
payday loans
xsmjatk http://paydayloansnsd.info/ payday loans 0961 http://paydayloansnsd.ca/ no fax pay day loan TpoGkK http://paydayloansnsd.com/ get money FqlgLh http://paydayloansnsd.co.uk/ quickquid wIpRpz
fast payday loan
kejrpact http://paydayloansnsb.com/ fast payday loan XCzTaa http://paydayloansnsb.ca/ pay day loan 6444 http://paydayloansnsb.co.uk/ pounds till payday jLzDhK http://paydayloansnsb.info/ payday loans 9353
pay day loan
weoqix http://paydayloansnsa.com/ pay day loan 9204 http://paydayloansnsa.ca/ pay day loan >:-OOO http://paydayloansnsa.co.uk/ payday loans online 7411 http://paydayloansnsa.info/ payday loan UqQvwC
pay day loans
hgmtqk http://paydayloansstk.info/ pay day loans 4311 http://paydayloansstj.us/ payday loans >:-OOO http://paydayloansstj.info/ payday loans uk :-O
no fax payday loans
ntjcqggd http://paydayloansstj.com/ no fax payday loans >:]] http://paydayloansstj.co.uk/ payday loans uk PsONfy http://paydayloansstj.ca/ payday loans npXJgC
cash advance
nmgtbs http://paydayloansmsc.com/ cash advance IHBLlf http://paydayloanssti.info/ payday loans wOHqz http://paydayloansstg.us/ payday loan 8]]] http://paydayloanssth.info/ payday loans 9791
South of Rome–West of Ellis Island | i-ITALY
As I web-site possessor I believe the content car insurance quotes matter here is rattling fantastic , appreciate it for your efforts. You should keep it up forever! Best of luck.
personal loans
qwjzifni http://paydayloansstg.com/ personal loans bDxpmz http://paydayloansstg.co.uk/ payday loans %-[[[ http://paydayloansstg.ca/ cash advance online RRqGdJ
payday loans online
rvmvszlc http://paydayloansptg.com/ payday loans online 1640 http://paydayloansptg.ca/ payday loans :-O http://paydayloansptg.co.uk/ payday loans 3869
payday loans uk
loyhpg http://paydayloansptm.co.uk/ payday loans uk =-] http://paydayloansptm.com/ payday loan >:]] http://paydayloansptm.ca/ payday loans IPLQv
payday loan
wbosdom http://paydayloansptl.com/ payday loan 6115 http://paydayloansptl.ca/ pay day loans 6351 http://paydayloansptl.co.uk/ Bad Credit Loans >:-OOO
cash advance
dzcywvue http://paydayloansptk.com/ cash advance HpmEHp http://paydayloansptk.ca/ cash advances uJAWP http://paydayloansptk.co.uk/ Bad Credit Loans 4181
Payday UK
ulhwih http://paydayloansptd.co.uk/ Payday UK :-O http://paydayloansptd.com/ cash advance 8788 http://paydayloansptd.ca/ no fax pay day loan >:-[
Payday advance
jinnref http://paydayloanspto.co.uk/ Payday advance jltVY http://paydayloanspto.com/ payday advance 8006 http://paydayloanspto.ca/ pay day loans 6412
payday cash
jvrppjud http://paydayloansptj.co.uk/ payday cash 8536 http://paydayloansptj.com/ fast payday loan 4007 http://paydayloansptj.ca/ no fax pay day loan TGGrJQ
payday loan
evgdjs http://paydayloansptc.com/ payday loan mGcHe http://paydayloansptc.ca/ cash advance online 8]]] http://paydayloansptc.co.uk/ Quick Quid :-O
payday advances
qcsnixky http://paydayloansptn.co.uk/ payday advances TFFjs http://paydayloansptn.com/ payday loan 6231 http://paydayloansptn.ca/ Cash Advance 4302
payday advances
wpptfy http://paydayloanspti.co.uk/ payday advances TDRXs http://paydayloanspti.com/ payday loans 8027 http://paydayloanspti.ca/ cash advances >:]]
quick payday loans
zvchlh http://paydayloansptb.com/ quick payday loans 6364 http://paydayloansptb.ca/ pay day loans pFbwj http://paydayloansptb.co.uk/ Bad Credit Loans %-[[[
Quick Quid
xxfdmsjv http://paydayloansvzx.co.uk/ Quick Quid >:]] http://paydayloansvzx.com/ cash advance :-O http://paydayloansvzx.ca/ no fax pay day loan 2854
payday loans
exrupb http://paydayloansvzi.com/ payday loans pWUMiK http://paydayloansvzi.ca/ payday loans >:-[ http://paydayloansvzi.co.uk/ payday loans 8]]]
personal loans
hvwano http://paydayloansvze.com/ personal loans >:-[ http://paydayloansvze.ca/ payday loans Canada ttkQfQ http://paydayloansvze.co.uk/ payday loans online 5877
payday loans online
rjawqj http://paydayloansvzh.com/ payday loans online =-] http://paydayloansvzh.ca/ payday loans canada =-] http://paydayloansvzh.co.uk/ quickquid 8]]]
payday loans
rlsckbh http://paydayloansvzd.co.uk/ payday loans 4316 http://paydayloansvzd.com/ instant payday loans >:-[ http://paydayloansvzd.ca/ pay day loans mgAJF
payday loan
eijmiz http://paydayloansvzj.co.uk/ payday loan EXOKB http://paydayloansvzj.com/ instant payday loans 3851 http://paydayloansvzj.ca/ payday loans online 0063
instant payday loans
hkhwxn http://paydayloansvzf.com/ instant payday loans 4030 http://paydayloansvzf.ca/ payday loans 7346 http://paydayloansvzf.co.uk/ quickquid 6971
payday loans online
mhrbeyq http://paydayloansmsb.com/ payday loans online >:-[ http://paydayloansvza.ca/ payday loans online VnpuIw http://paydayloansvza.co.uk/ quick quid 8671
quickquid
qlmhujer http://paydaylaonsffj.co.uk/ quickquid FSDbSz http://paydaylaonsffj.com/ pay day loans 9517
payday loans online
elenvoub http://paydayloanslcj.com/ payday loans online QhlmVH http://paydayloanslcj.ca/ payday loans Canada HsOOC http://paydayloanslcj.co.uk/ Bad Credit Loans >:]]
Quick Quid
idwmhy http://paydaylaonsffi.co.uk/ Quick Quid >:]] http://paydaylaonsffi.com/ quick payday loans GMQKG
Payday UK
yhxmyjn http://paydayloanslch.co.uk/ Payday UK myiheY http://paydayloanslch.com/ payday loans|Bad Credit Loans XkuDgo http://paydayloanslch.ca/ pay day loan 4763
payday loans
vpzdoqu http://paydayloanslci.com/ payday loans byhEPS http://paydayloanslci.ca/ payday loans Canada 0695 http://paydayloanslci.co.uk/ payday cash 0367
no fax payday loans
juwrziqz http://paydaylaonsffh.com/ no fax payday loans yqnkpC http://paydaylaonsffh.ca/ payday loans >:-[ http://paydaylaonsffh.co.uk/ Payday UK CRdcR
payday Advance uk
btlodah http://paydayloanslcg.co.uk/ payday Advance uk 2647 http://paydayloanslcg.com/ quick payday loans 7567 http://paydayloanslcg.ca/ Cash Advance 8]]]
fast cash advance
sfajrh http://paydaylaonsffg.com/ fast cash advance ClCQt http://paydaylaonsffg.ca/ pay day loans HeGrFV http://paydaylaonsffg.co.uk/ payday loans online >:]]
Quick Quid
zhmife http://paydayloanslcf.co.uk/ Quick Quid haajHA http://paydayloanslcf.com/ payday loans >:-[ http://paydayloanslcf.ca/ cash advance online CCbDXz
quick quid
nprvcvi http://paydaylaonsfff.co.uk/ quick quid =-] http://paydaylaonsfff.com/ quick payday loans 9385 http://paydaylaonsfff.ca/ cash advances Mfuwe
same day loan
ozumdr http://paydayloanslce.co.uk/ same day loan QfGUD http://paydayloanslce.com/ cash advance >:-OOO http://paydayloanslce.ca/ payday loans >:-[
payday loan
psxzqvd http://paydaylaonsffe.com/ payday loan >:]] http://paydaylaonsffe.ca/ no fax pay day loans >:-[ http://paydaylaonsffe.co.uk/ payday cash =-]
instant Payday Loans
lwxjtn http://paydayloanslcd.co.uk/ instant Payday Loans 5656 http://paydayloanslcd.com/ payday advance >:-OOO http://paydayloanslcd.ca/ payday loans gTjAwU
payday advance
wiynnuix http://paydaylaonsffd.com/ payday advance lDXsw http://paydaylaonsffd.ca/ Cash Advance 2128 http://paydayloansmsa.com/ payday loan woXAe http://paydaylaonsffd.co.uk/ Payday advance >:-OOO
payday advance
lhtgpahk http://paydayloanslcc.com/ payday advance TzmlB http://paydayloanslcc.ca/ no fax pay day loan 0152 http://paydayloanslcc.co.uk/ quick quid 2957
payday cash
vaxyok http://paydaylaonsffb.co.uk/ payday cash 9344 http://paydaylaonsffb.com/ pay day loan kFwAFS http://paydaylaonsffb.ca/ no fax pay day loans 4776
payday cash
kkbdph http://paydayloanslca.co.uk/ payday cash >:-[ http://paydayloanslca.com/ fast payday loan 9994 http://paydayloanslca.ca/ payday loans Canada 3982
payday Advance uk
tocafyx http://paydaylaonsffa.co.uk/ payday Advance uk 6418 http://paydaylaonsffa.com/ payday advance qOHDKz http://paydaylaonsffa.ca/ payday Canada 9058