Sign in | Log in

The Italian Election: American Voters and “The Southern Question”

The Italian Election: American Voters and “The Southern Question”

Tom Verso (April 24, 2008)

Comments posted by i-Italy bloggers Stanton Burnett and Marina Melchionda regarding the recent Italian elections place the outcome of that election solidly in the 150 year tradition conceptualize and characterized as “The Southern Question?”

Tools

 In 1860 Garibaldi’s army “liberated” the people of southern Italy. However, the people did not feel liberated.

They revolted against what they perceived to be a conquering northern Italian regime. A vicious civil war ensued between the southern “Brigandage” and a northern Piedmont Army that razed whole southern towns such as Pontelandolfo for supporting the “Brigandage”.

 
As the war dragged on for years, bleeding the northern military and treasury, northerners became preoccupied with the south; giving rise in the 1870’s to a journalistic and literary tradition know as “The Southern Question”. Specifically, the question: ‘what could be done to incorporate the people of the south into a harmonious nation state –Italy’? By the 1880’s the federal government had de facto (if not de jure) decided upon a radical solution to the problem – export it. 
 
Back in 1863 Nino Bixio, while working for a parliamentary commission inquiring into the problem of the Brigandage, wrote “… [southern Italy] is a country that should be depopulated and its inhabitants sent to Africa…” That same year the parliament passed the “Pica Law which grafted transportation onto the system of punishment”; i.e. southerners were transported away from their homes for supporting the revolution (see: “Darkest Italy” by John Dickie). Ideas of depopulation became a reality with the mass emigration of millions of southern Italians between circa 1880 and 1920.
 
However, the Southern Question persisted as evidence by Gramsci’s renowned article by that name in 1926. While the Fascists were not sympathetic to his communist analysis, they fully recognized the need to deal with the question. Traveling in Sicily in 1936, Jerre Mangione (“Mount Allegro”), albeit in anti-Fascist mocking tones, reports seeing Fascist public works projects and attempts to increase the efficiency of the train system, which was necessary for an efficient economy.
 
On June 2nd 1946Italy celebrated the birth of the Republic. The Fascist and the House of Savoy monarchy (that the Brigandage fought) were gone; but, not the Southern Question. In 1962, Luigi Barsini devoted a chapter in his book “The Italians”, to “the ancient and puzzling Problem del Mezzogiorno” (i.e. the Southern Question.)
 
In 1983 Nelson Moe (an American student in Perugia) on a train trip, indicated to a lady that he was going to Naples. Her reply: “Didn’t I know that this was a filthy, dangerous city, full of hucksters and thieves? Didn’t I know that the south was like Africa?”  Her vehemence so stunned him and stimulated his interest that he eventually researched and wrote “The View from Vesuvius: Italian Culture and the Southern Question.” In 1998 interest in the question had not waned: CUNY anthropologist Jane Schneider published a multidiscipline anthology of essays “Italy’s ‘Southern Question.” In 2002 the scholarly interests continued with the publication of an extraordinary source document study; “Darkest Italy: The Nation and the Stereotypes of the Mezzogiorno, 1860-1900” by John Dickie.
 
Finally, this month two i-Italy bloggers placed the recent Italian election solidly in the Southern Question tradition:
 
“That the South is a serious drag on Italian economic performance in the context of the new Europe is no new revelation. Stefano Vaccara and I, in a study published in 1999 by Washington’s Center for Strategic and International Studies, found that not only was the North-South gap dramatic, but that the trends were in the wrong direction, a situation that was largely masked in Brussels where most economic and social statistics are national statistics.” (Stanton H. Burnett April 11, 2008 “Understanding Italian Politics”)
 
“Most of the votes [Berlusconi] has gained come from the South of Italy, where unemployment and economic discomfort afflict a larger portion of the population…“the “Southern question” is still a big issue here in Italy. In effect I could easily affirm that it is gaining much more political relevance nowadays with unemployment growing in the South as many companies are closing…the Southern question is gaining renovated relevancy, so much that both Berlusconi and Veltroni have made of it one of the most important issues, if the not THE most important, of their electoral campaign…Berlusconi is seen as the answer to all southern problems. He promised to solve the garbage crisis in Naples, to put – once again – the Southern question at the top of his political agenda” (Marina Melchionda April 15, 2008 “Opinions on Italian Elections” –comment section)
 
In conclusion, no matter how proficient Americans of Italian descent become in Italian language conjugations and declensions, or how many trips they take to ancient and Renaissance Italian tourist sites, they will not know their heritage or be able to vote meaningfully in Italian elections unless and until they know and understand “The Southern Question.”

DISCLAIMER: Posts published in i-Italy are intended to stimulate a debate in the Italian and Italian-American Community and sometimes deal with controversial issues. The Editors are not responsible for, nor necessarily in agreement with the views presented by individual contributors.
© ALL RIGHTS RESERVED - RIPRODUZIONE VIETATA.
This work may not be reproduced, in whole or in part, without prior written permission.
Questo lavoro non può essere riprodotto, in tutto o in parte, senza permesso scritto.

dice Red Pepper...

The British leftist online magazine Red Pepper has much interesting commentary on the elections.

http://www.redpepper.org.uk/article1225.html

Some say the fact that the opposition has been whittled down to Veltroni's Democrats is a good thing. But as the article at Red Pepper notes, the Democrats are a copy, or "brutta copia" of "New" Labour and its centrism.

Yes, but what is it that

Yes, but what is it that Italian Americans are supposed to learn from the "southern question" and how should that knowledge affect the votes of those IAs who also hold Italian citizenship? That those who are happy that the "psiconano" will return to power should realize that Berlusconi can't and won't deliver on his promises to the south, just as during his two previous stints as premier? That his dependence upon the virulently racist and anti-Mezzogiorno Lega Nord just might affect how the "centrodestra" addresses the problems of the south? That the return of Berlusconi and his corrupt and reactionary allies will mean the "lotta contro la mafia" will be stalled and, more likely,halted?

“I calls ‘em as I sees ‘em”

My fundamental epistemological/ontological assumption about the nature of social phenomena is that any manifestation at any point in time is the product of historic antecedents. Accordingly, rational decision making entails knowledge of those antecedents. I was stuck by Stanton Burnett’s and Marina Melchionda’s (whom I take to be highly informed observers of Italy) comments placing the current election and more generally the social conditions of Italy, as I said, “solidly in the 150 year Southern Question tradition”. /// I won’t presume to say “what an Italian American (or anyone else for that matter) is supposed to learn” or how they should vote. The social/historical lesson I draw is that the issues facing Italy generally and the South particularly will not be resolved by this or that particular politician or election. The problems associated with the Southern Question will persist no matter who wins the election! Its 150 year history demonstrates that unequivocally - Monarchs, Fascist, Communist, Christian Democrats; the list goes on and on. Similarly, your point about the mafia and why I choose the Bataglia picture to complement my piece. The mafia has been around for at least as long as the Southern Question. Berlusconi is irrelevant. Both will be here after he passes from this life. //// I think an analogy in the US is that no matter who wins the next election, the Iraq/Afghanistan war will continue. The historic/social antecedents that brought us that war are not going to be overridden by an election. The character of the war may change (e.g. more or less bombing) but the objectives will not change; similarly, trade policies that have virtually destroyed American heavy industry. //// In short, an historian cannot advise how to vote. S/he can only posit the probabilities that your vote will achieve its objective. The probability that the Iraq war will end or American trade policies will change is low. The probability that the Southern Question issues will be resolved is very much lower. What are the implications of that? I don't know! The model of an excellent historian to me is the proverbial umpire who said: “I calls ‘em as I sees ‘em”. //// Thank for your comment. Like Socrates, I believe that knowledge can only be attained through dialogue. Tom Verso

A nuisance to be ceased

Mr Verso: following my comment of Dec 2006 (SIX YEARS AGO!!!) about this subject, my "in" e-mail box has been flooded and afflicted by a series of about 13 "spam" messages (most making no sense at all, some advertising Viagra [no, thank you...]) that have been regularly notified by me. If this was "punishment" allowed by you for my giving a comment that didn't suit your obvious opinions about southern Italy, Sicilia, etc., I don't know and I couldn't care less. But I am pointing out to you that all this junk clutters YOUR blog, too: are you that anxious to keep it??!!! I think you'd better eliminate it (I'm sure that, being the blogger, you CAN do it) and prevent this nuisance to keep bothering me. For me it's easy to eliminate: I just dump it. It should be in your interest, also, to get rid of it. As to the contents and trend of your blog, it's evident that you and I, for what concerns Southern Italy and that unmentionable triangular island at its toe, are at positions opposite by 180°. I trust you will dispose of this nuisance.

A nuisance to be ceased

Mr Verso: following my comment of Dec 2006 (SIX YEARS AGO!!!) about this subject, my "in" e-mail box has been flooded and afflicted by a series of about 13 "spam" messages (most making no sense at all, some advertising Viagra [no, thank you...]) that have been regularly notified by me. If this was "punishment" allowed by you for my giving a comment that didn't suit your obvious opinions about southern Italy, Sicilia, etc., I don't know and I couldn't care less. But I am pointing out to you that all this junk clutters YOUR blog, too: are you that anxious to keep it??!!! I think you'd better eliminate it (I'm sure that, being the blogger, you CAN do it) and prevent this nuisance to keep bothering me. For me it's easy to eliminate: I just dump it. It should be in your interest, also, to get rid of it. As to the contents and trend of your blog, it's evident that you and I, for what concerns Southern Italy and that unmentionable triangular island at its toe, are at positions opposite by 180°. I trust you will dispose of this nuisance.

A nuisance to be ceased

Mr Verso: following my comment of Dec 2006 (SIX YEARS AGO!!!) about this subject, my "in" e-mail box has been flooded and afflicted by a series of about 13 "spam" messages (most making no sense at all, some advertising Viagra [no, thank you...]) that have been regularly notified by me. If this was "punishment" allowed by you for my giving a comment that didn't suit your obvious opinions about southern Italy, Sicilia, etc., I don't know and I couldn't care less. But I am pointing out to you that all this junk clutters YOUR blog, too: are you that anxious to keep it??!!! I think you'd better eliminate it (I'm sure that, being the blogger, you CAN do it) and prevent this nuisance to keep bothering me. For me it's easy to eliminate: I just dump it. It should be in your interest, also, to get rid of it. As to the contents and trend of your blog, it's evident that you and I, for what concerns Southern Italy and that unmentionable triangular island at its toe, are at positions opposite by 180°. I trust you will dispose of this nuisance.

I clearly comprehend that

I clearly comprehend that the understanding specified is related to just about every person . Thank you . Locksmith Hartford CT Plantation FL Locksmith Locksmith Fremont CA miami fl locksmith locksmith fort worth texas Locksmith Washington Atlanta Locksmiths Washington Locksmith Memphis TN Locksmith Locksmith Washington Washington Locksmith Memphis Locksmiths Locksmith Atlanta GA Locksmith Hampton VA Hampton Locksmith Locksmith Hampton VA Corona Locksmiths Lakewood Locksmith Norwalk FL Plumbing Locksmith Plantation Locksmith Garland Locksmith Linden NJ Locksmith Washington Locksmith Atlanta Locksmith Irving Locksmith West palm beach Oak Lawn Locksmith Wellington Locksmith Locksmiths Hawthorne Haddon Township Locksmiths Rancho Cucamonga Locksmiths Locksmiths Corona Locksmiths Irvington Locksmiths Bell Locksmith in norwalk Locksmith in Henderson Locksmith Kent Locksmith Elizabeth Locksmith in Belleville Locksmith Arcadia Locksmith Detroit MI Indianapolis IN Locksmith Dallas Locksmiths Houston Locksmiths Long Beach Locksmiths Bayonne FL Locksmith Locksmith Hawthorne CA Locksmith Warren Locksmith Garfield NJ locksmith Glendale AZ http://www.portlandlocksmithbest.com